Focus Group Report Pt 1: Patients’ Views on the Broken Healthcare System

May 4, 2026
Maryann Cousens

This Navigator Research report focuses on how Americans view the healthcare system and their greatest pain points. *Three focus groups were conducted online on April 23, 2026, among Americans in battleground states who are insured through the ACA marketplace and have seen their premiums increase, who are uninsured, and patient-facing healthcare providers. We recruited a mix across partisanship, education, gender, and race. Qualitative results are not statistically projectable.

Big Takeaways:

Healthcare costs are a major financial pain point, with many participants saying they have to choose between paying for healthcare and other basics like food or rent.

Skipping doctor visits, getting medical advice from AI, turning to less expensive holistic remedies, and doing hours of research, were among the strategies participants cited using to avoid incurring costs from doctor or hospital visits.

Many attributed the recent rise in healthcare costs to the Republican tax law – though participants didn’t express confidence in either party’s ability to fight for them and lower costs or reform the broken healthcare system.

Some form of universal healthcare – however defined or labeled – was seen as solving a range of problems with our healthcare system.

Healthcare Costs Are Major Stressor

Participants cited healthcare costs as a major financial stressor in their lives, with many saying costs have increased to such an extent they have to choose between healthcare and other necessities.

  • “I went shopping for healthcare and decided I can either have healthcare or I can eat and pay rent.” – NC woman, uninsured
  • “I’m a contractor, so I have to get my own insurance off the marketplace. And it quadrupled this year…They used to give you breaks, and now it’s four times as much.” – MI woman, ACA marketplace

Many Attribute Increase in Costs to Republican Budget Bill

Without priming, some participants organically brought up the Republican tax law, also known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, as a culprit for their most recent rise in healthcare costs.

  • “They got rid of the subsidies, so your premiums alone skyrocketed. And then just even an office visit now, I think mine is, I don’t know, 50, 60 bucks, and before it was 20. So I think that’s what you can attribute it to.” – MI woman, ACA marketplace
  • “I think what has happened in Washington in the last year has not made them go down. I think it has made the plans generally go up and the coverage less robust, generally speaking.” – NV man, ACA marketplace

Most Say they Avoid Going to the Doctor 

Avoiding doctor visits is a primary strategy for saving on healthcare costs, with many saying something catastrophic would have to occur for them to seek medical care.

  • “I’m a single mom, so for me, if my daughter needs to go, that’s who’s going. She’s going before me. So yeah, I’m going less and reserving the appointments for her if I have to.” – GA woman, ACA subsidies
  • “I don’t have the funds to be like, ‘I’m going to go to the urgent care for a cough.’ So then you weigh the, is this serious? Is this not? And so far, I’ve just not gone.” – NC woman, uninsured

Participants Cite Range of Strategies for Avoiding Health Care System Altogether 

From AI to holistic remedies to spending hours on research, participants have found ways to cope with their lack of access to affordable healthcare options.

  • “I talk to ChatGPT about anything. I’ve sent it pictures of my freckles, I’ve asked it if this fever and this symptom…AI will tell me if I should see a doctor or not. That or call my mom, and she’ll be like, ‘Oh, Google this or go to WebMD.'” – NC woman, uninsured
  • “I have been trying to figure out Medigap, all the different plans for that. There’s all of these different letters, A, B, C, D, E, F, G. It goes up to N, I believe. Probably in the last week, I have dedicated probably at least 30 hours reading about this…It’s almost like it’s made to be confusing.” – PA woman, ACA marketplace

Insurance Companies Seen as Obvious Villain

Though the Republican tax law is seen as responsible for recent hikes in healthcare costs, insurance companies are seen as the real villains of a broken healthcare system.

  • “I’ve had coverage and times when I’ve not had coverage. And for me to go in there and for instance, have to have something that is $1,000 if I have coverage, but when I don’t have coverage, it’s $250, it’s 75% less. How is that possible? It just goes to show how much we’re being robbed through healthcare, through healthcare companies.” – AZ man, uninsured
  • “We’ve got a lot of insurance companies that are calling the shots versus the doctors calling the shots, and the insurance companies and the middlemen are siphoning all the money out of the system, and it’s a bad system.” – NC man, ACA marketplace

Neither Party Seen as Fighting to Fix Healthcare

Participants expressed feeling like nobody in Washington is fighting for them – no matter the political party. Many felt hopeless that either party could solve the deep-rooted issues within the U.S. healthcare system because many politicians are perceived as beholden to corporate or donor interests instead of helping everyday people.

  • “I just feel like it’s no matter who’s running it, even if the Democrats tried to solve it or fix it or come back and make a change, I don’t feel like there’s enough momentum to undo what’s already been done, I guess.” – NC woman, uninsured
  • “I think that they share the same vision, be them right or left, Democrat, Republican. If they’re a politician in this country as part of the government, their only goal is to line their pockets and steal from the people as much money as possible and facilitate large corporations to be able to do whatever they want to us.” – AZ man, uninsured
Slide from Navigator Research titled: Yet Many Just See "Both Parties" As To Blame For The Current State Of Care, Or Admit They Are Unsure

Democrats Seen as More Likely to Fix the Healthcare System

Participants associated affordable and universal healthcare plans with Democrats, saying it’s more aligned with their platform. Skepticism remained on Democrats’ ability to execute healthcare plans.

  • “I think the Democrats would be more about changing it. Some of those things you talked about, like perhaps the Medicare for All or universal coverage, I think they would do that more because they’re more about support for people and healthcare, and they’re the ones who came up with the Affordable Care Act.” – NV man, ACA marketplace
  • “Democrats are more universal. They all say for all.They all say for all. But no matter who’s in office, it always seems to be the same, right?” – AZ woman, uninsured
Slide from Navigator Research titled: Democrats More Likely To Be Seen As The Party Fighting For More Universal Or Affordable Care

Participants Say Change is Needed, Universal Healthcare Seen as Obvious Solution

Nearly every participant said they wished healthcare was universal – which carried a range of definitions across participants – but boiled down to a basic healthcare plan that all Americans could afford no matter their job or income level.

  • “There should, in my opinion, be a basic health plan that covers maybe 80%. And then if you want to buy something for the rest, then you can do that.” – NV man, ACA marketplace
  • “Healthcare should be a basic human right. And not having that, there should be something that should be done about that.” – MI man, uninsured
  • “Personally, as a tattoo artist, I hear so many artists never have insurance or anything like that. It would be nice to know if, say, if I broke my hand, I can go to a hospital. Other countries, I can get it fixed. Here, it’s all on me.” – NV man, uninsured
Slide from Navigator Research Titled: Nearly All Wish Our Healthcare System Was "Universal" And "Affordable"

Participants Don’t Know the Difference Between “Universal,” “Single Payer,” “Medicare for All” or “Public Option”

Though some form of universal healthcare was seen as a solution to fixing the healthcare system, few could define “universal,” “single payer,” “Medicare for all,” and “public option.” Communicators need to keep this in mind, while Washington may be debating what is the best branding for this fight, Americans are concerned about access and cost of healthcare.

  • “I’m familiar with universal healthcare, but the rest of them…I’ve heard of Medicare, but the rest of them, no, I have not heard of.” – GA woman, ACA marketplace
  • [Moderator: What about Medicare for All? What’s that mean?] “That’s a good question. What does that mean?” – AZ man, uninsured
Slide from Navigator Research titled: Yet Not Many Can Identify The Difference Between "Universal," "Single Payer," "Medicare for All," Or "Public Option"

Part 1 of this report covers the first two groups: those insured through the ACA marketplace and those who are uninsured. Part 2 will summarize the findings from our patient-facing healthcare provider group.

Download
Slide Deck
Share

About The Study

On April 23, 2026, GBAO conducted three online focus groups in battleground states* with voters who get health insurance through the ACA marketplace, recently uninsured voters, and patient-facing health care professionals.

Related Posts

READ MORE
January 21, 2026

Focus Group Report: Trump Regrets … They’ve Had A Few

Focus group report on Americans in battleground states who voted for Trump in 2024 and expressed regret or misgivings about their vote.

Julie Alderman Boudreau
December 03, 2025

Focus Group Report: Working Class Americans and the Affordability Crisis

Focus group report that covers groups conducted among working class Americans in Senate battleground states on their personal financial situations, their greatest economic concerns, and perceptions of elected officials tackling affordability.

Rachael Russell, Ian Smith & Maryann Cousens