Focus Group Report: Perceptions of the Economy among independents and soft partisans in Arizona, Wisconsin, and upstate New York

June 22, 2023
Gabriela Parra

Findings from a focus group that focused on perceptions of the economy in Arizona, Wisconsin, and upstate New York.

Methodology

On June 13, 2023, GBAO conducted three focus groups online with independents and soft partisans in AZ-1, NY-19, and WI-1.

Key takeaways

  • Despite broad pessimism, views on the economy are now mixed.
  • Knowledge of Congress’ record on the economy is thin. And Democrats’ vision on the economy is not particularly clear.
  • Our three example members are not well-known, although a handful know of Schweikert’s ethics problems.
  • “Specifics” tend to shift constituents negatively—whether they’re specific allegations against members or insulin prices.
  • Member-specific criticisms are more effective than describing representatives as part of the “MAGA” movement.
  • Few seem to be following the Supreme Court closely, but trust in the Court is split, with participants citing Dobbs.

Views on the Economy Are Now Mixed

Views on the Future Economy Are More Positive

Although Pessimism Is Still Widespread

Little Awareness of Congress’ Actions on the Economy or Health Care

The Republican Vision for the Economy Is Clearer Than the Democratic Vision

The Members Examined Are Mostly Not Well-Known

Top Concerns About Members Largely Focus on Specifics, Whether it Be Policy or Questionable Ethics

Enumerated GOP Cuts Are Shocking

Some Find It Hard To Believe Members Would Hold These Positions, But Move With “Standalone Bill” Proof

Others Explain Some Messages Don’t Affect Them Personally

Messages Make Members Seem “Crooked” or Lacking Empathy, Prioritizing Corporations Over People

Animals Further Suggest Members Are Vulnerable

Member-Specific Criticisms Stronger Than MAGA Attacks

SCOTUS Awareness Is Thin, but Most Are Doubtful the Court Will Make the Right Decisions in the Future

Share

About The Study

GBAO conducted three online focus groups on June 13, 2023 with independents and soft partisans in AZ-1, NY19, and WI-1. Some quotes have been lightly edited for brevity. Qualitative results are not statistically projectable.

Related Posts

READ MORE
November 06, 2026

Americans Are Done Waiting: What the 2026 Midterms Told Us

A Navigator special report on what the 2026 midterms told us about the desire for change and need to deliver.

Navigator Research
October 29, 2026

Boomers Watch, Gen Z Scrolls: A Generational News Divide Consumption and Awareness

Today’s report contains data collected by Navigator throughout 2026 on the news stories that Americans followed and didn’t through 2026.

Julie Alderman Boudreau
October 22, 2026

Mother Knows Best: Why Moms Regret Voting for Trump

This is a special report from Navigating the Vote containing findings from a focus group conducted with white suburban moms who voted for President Trump in 2024 but now regret their vote.

Julie Alderman Boudreau and Avery Smedley
October 16, 2026

Navigating the Vote: Buyer’s Remorse: Gen Z on Trump

This Navigating the Vote report covers Gen Z voters who supported President Trump in 2024 but now regret their vote.

Abigail Xu and Tina Tang